TITLE 16. ECONOMIC REGULATION

PART 2. PUBLIC UTILITY COMMISSION OF TEXAS

CHAPTER 24. SUBSTANTIVE RULES APPLICABLE TO WATER AND SEWER SERVICE PROVIDERS

SUBCHAPTER B. RATES AND TARIFFS

16 TAC §24.41

The Public Utility Commission of Texas (commission) amends 16 Texas Administrative Code (TAC) §24.41 relating to Cost of Service. The commission adopts this rule with no changes to the proposed text as published in the September 25, 2026 issue of the Texas Register (51 TexReg 6650). The rule will not be republished. The adopted rule defines the expenses that are prohibited from inclusion as components of cost of service. The adopted rule also identifies certain criteria related to ratemaking rate base and establishes the timing for commission review of transaction and closing costs associated with the acquisition for sales, transfers, or mergers that involve a fair market valuation under 16 TAC §24.238, relating to Fair Market Valuation.

The adopted rule removes rule provisions that were inadvertently omitted due to scrivener's error under Project 59086 and not proposed for amendment as part of that rulemaking proceeding. The restored provisions are directly reflective of statutory language and well-established commission interpretations House Bill 2712, as enacted by the 89th Texas Legislature (R.S.)The amended rule also makes minor clerical and stylistic changes.

The commission received no public comments under Project Number 59086.

The amended rule is adopt under the following provisions of the Texas Water Code: §13.041(a), which provides the commission the general power to regulate and supervise the business of each public utility within its jurisdiction and to do anything specifically designated or implied by the Texas Water Code that is necessary and convenient to the exercise of that power and jurisdiction; Texas Water Code §13.041(b), which provides the commission with the authority to adopt and enforce rules reasonably required in the exercise of its powers and jurisdiction; Texas Water Code §13.185(b) which requires that utility rates to be based on the original cost of property used by and useful to the utility during the test year in providing service; Texas Water Code §13.185(g) which authorizes the commission to promulgate reasonable rules and regulations with respect to the allowance or disallowance of certain expenses for ratemaking purposes; and Texas Water Code §13.305 which prescribes the ratemaking rate base associated with the acquisition of a water or sewer utility.

Cross Reference to Statute: Texas Water Code §§13.041(a) and (b); 13.185(b) and (g); 13.305.

The agency certifies that legal counsel has reviewed the adoption and found it to be a valid exercise of the agency's legal authority.

Filed with the Office of the Secretary of State on November 5, 2026.

TRD-202604666

Katelyn Lewis

Rules Coordinator

Public Utility Commission of Texas

Effective date: November 25, 2026

Proposal publication date: September 25, 2026

For further information, please call: (512) 936-7044


SUBCHAPTER J. WHOLESALE WATER OR SEWER SERVICE

16 TAC §§24.307, 24.309, 24.311

The Public Utility Commission of Texas (commission) adopts amendments to §24.307 relating to Commission's Review of Petition or Appeal Concerning Wholesale Rate, §24.309 relating to Evidentiary Hearing on Public Interest, and §24.311 relating to Determination of Public Interest with changes to the proposed text as published in the May 22, 2026, issue of the Texas Register (51 TexReg 3492). The rules are adopted in Project No. 53981. The rules will be republished.

These adopted rules will implement Texas Water Code §12.013 and §13.0431 as revised by Senate Bill (SB) 997 during the Texas 87th Regular Legislative Session, which establishes that a party adversely affected by a public interest determination may appeal the decision to a court of proper jurisdiction. The adopted rules will allow the commission to make a determination as to whether the protested rate is charged under a contract and allow the commission to consider cost of service evidence when evaluating whether a wholesale seller's rate is in the public interest.  The commission also makes a number of minor revisions to the proposed rules to clarify intent, align with statutory language, and eliminate unnecessary or duplicative language.

The commission received comments from Texas Water Association (TWA) and Texas Association of Water Companies (TAWC).

Proposed §24.307(e) - Determination if a rate is charged under the contract

Proposed §24.307(e) allows the commission to determine if the disputed rate was charged under the contract.

TWA opposes the amended language in proposed §24.307(e) as overly broad and confusing as the commission lacks the authority to adjudicate breach of contract claims. TWA argued that when parties disagree about whether the rate is pursuant to the contract, the Commission's exercise of its jurisdiction must be paused for a court of proper jurisdiction to resolve the breach-of-contract claim as per the existing rule. As such, TWA recommended deleting the additions to §24.307(e) in the proposal for publication.

Commission Response

The commission declines to remove the additions to proposed §24.307(e), as recommended by TWA. Texas courts have repeatedly held that an agency with exclusive or primary jurisdiction may decide issues that require interpreting contracts when necessary to exercise its statutory jurisdiction. TWC §12.013 empowers the commission to fix reasonable rates for the furnishing of water for any purpose mentioned in chapter 11 or 12 of the TWC. This statute predates most if not all existing water and sewer service contracts, making the statute part of the contract terms. The commission, in exercising its rate authority under TWC § 12.103, is not making an adjudication of a contract but simply an application of the terms of the contract.

The Third Court of Appeals has also determined in Texas Water Commission v. City of Fort Worth that an agency with statutory authorization can review the reasonableness of contractual rates where the public interest is affected. Because the proposed rules require an initial determination that the contracted rates are not in the public interest, the rules are in alignment with both statutory language and judicial precedent on this topic.

Finally, the commission notes that this application is to solely to determine which procedural track at the commission is best suited to handle the issue between the parties, not to adjudicate the terms of the contract presented to the commission or SOAH.

Proposed §24.311(b) - Factors considered in a public interest determination

Proposed §24.311(b) allows the commission to consider all relevant factors in determining whether the protested rate adversely affects the public interest, including an analysis of the seller's cost of service.

TWA opposes the proposed change in §24.311(b) which allows for an analysis of the seller's cost of service as a factor in determining whether the protested rate adversely affects the public interest. TWA explained that considering cost of service would result in a significant change in the commission's consideration of these cases and further commented that the proposed change exceeds the scope of SB 997. TWA requested §24.311(b) remain as it does in the existing rule, which only allows for consideration of cost of service if the second phase of a rate appeal is reached. TAWC recommends clarifying the types of "cost of service" evidence the commission will consider in determining whether a protested wholesale rate adversely affects the public interest and whether that evidence is distinct from "cost of service" evidence the commission will consider for wholesale rate-setting.

Commission Response

While the commission agrees that the public interest determination is not based solely on whether the challenged rates match the cost of service, the cost of providing service may be a relevant factor in determining whether the rate charged harms the public interest. For example, if the cost of providing service has decreased significantly from the time the contract was entered into, increases in wholesale rates may reflect an abuse of monopoly power. The existing rule framework for wholesale water rate appeals was set by the Texas Natural Resource Conservation Commission (now the Texas Commission on Environmental Quality) under the presumption that the parties involved are sophisticated, have options to acquire water supply, and that rates charged under a contract are just and reasonable. When the commission obtained jurisdiction over water and sewer rates, these rules were transferred over to the commission without edit, but with the understanding that rulemakings would follow to refine the economic regulation of water and sewer water utilities. The commission declines to remove the proposed changes to proposed §24.311(b).

The commission acknowledges that the proposed language did not limit the analysis or type of evidence related to cost of service that may be relevant. At the public interest stage, a full rate case analysis of the seller's cost of service is inappropriate. This rule revision is merely intended to allow the presiding officer the flexibility to consider cost of service or specific components of cost of service as a consideration when analyzing whether the proposed rate harms the public interest. As such, the commission modifies proposed §24.311(b) to state, "the commission may consider all relevant factors in determining whether the protested rate harms the public interest, including evidence of the seller's cost of service."

Statutory Authority

These amendments are adopted under Texas Water Code §12.013, which provides the commission rate-fixing power over water furnished by a political subdivision to another political subdivision on a wholesale basis; Texas Water Code §13.0431(f) which requires the commission to determine that the amount charged under the contract harms the public interest prior to holding a hearing on just and reasonable amounts to be charged under the contract. Texas Water Code §13.041(a), which provides the commission the general power to regulate and supervise the business of each public utility within its jurisdiction and to do anything specifically designated or implied by the Texas Water Code that is necessary and convenient to the exercise of that power and jurisdiction; and Texas Water Code §13.041(b), which provides the commission with the authority to adopt and enforce rules reasonably required in the exercise of its powers and jurisdiction.

Cross Reference to Statute: Texas Water Code §12.013; §13.041(a); and §13.041(b).

§24.307. Commission's Review of Petition or Appeal Concerning Wholesale Rate.

(a) When a petition or appeal is filed, the commission must determine within 30 days of the filing of the petition or appeal whether the petition contains all of the information required by this subchapter. For purposes of this section only, the initial review of probable grounds must be limited to a determination whether the petitioner has met the requirements §24.305 of this title (relating to Petition or Appeal). If the commission determines that the petition or appeal does not meet the requirements of §24.305 of this title, the commission must inform the petitioner of the deficiencies within the petition or appeal and allow the petitioner the opportunity to correct these deficiencies. If the commission determines that the petition or appeal does meet the requirements of §24.305 of this title, the commission must forward the petition or appeal to the State Office of Administrative Hearings for an evidentiary hearing. The scope of the evidentiary hearing will be as determined by subsection (c), (d), or (e), as applicable.

(b) For the purposes of this subchapter, a rate is charged under a written contract if the decision establishing the rate was subject to or based upon the terms of a written contract executed between the seller and buyer.

(c) For a petition or appeal to review a rate where the seller and buyer agree that the protested rate is charged under a written contract, the commission will forward the petition or appeal to the State Office of Administrative Hearings to conduct an evidentiary hearing to determine whether the amount charged under the contract harms the public interest.

(d) For a petition or appeal to review a rate where the seller and buyer agree that the protested rate is not charged under a written contract, the commission will forward the petition or appeal to the State Office of Administrative Hearings to conduct an evidentiary hearing on the rate.

(e) For a petition or appeal to review a rate where the seller and buyer disagree whether the protested rate is charged under a written contract, the commission will forward the petition or appeal to the State Office of Administrative Hearings to conduct an evidentiary hearing to determine whether the rate is charged under a written contract. The administrative law judge will prepare a proposal for decision addressing whether the protested rate is charged under a contract for consideration by the commission.

(1) If the rate is found to be charged under a written contract, the commission will forward the petition or appeal to the State Office of Administrative Hearings to conduct an evidentiary hearing to determine whether the amount charged under the contract harms the public interest.

(2) If the rate is found to not be charged under a written contract, the commission will forward the petition or appeal to the State Office of Administrative Hearings to conduct an evidentiary hearing on the rate.

§24.309. Evidentiary Hearing on Public Interest.

(a) If the commission forwards a petition or appeal to the State Office of Administrative Hearings pursuant to §24.307(a) and (c) of this title (relating to Commission's Review of Petition or Appeal Concerning Wholesale Rate) for an evidentiary hearing, the scope of the hearing will be limited to determining whether the amount charged under the contract harms the public interest.

(b) Prior to the evidentiary hearing on public interest, discovery will be limited to matters relevant to the public interest determination.

(c) The seller and buyer may agree to consolidate the evidentiary hearing on public interest and the evidentiary hearing on the rate. If the seller and buyer agree to consolidation, then the administrative law judge must hold a consolidated evidentiary hearing.

(d) If a party adversely affected by the public interest determination in a hearing under this section appeals the decision to a court of proper jurisdiction, the presiding officer will abate proceedings on the contract until the appeal is resolved.

§24.311. Determination on Public Interest.

(a) The commission may consider all relevant factors in determining whether the protested rate harms the public interest, including evidence of the seller's cost of service.

(b) The commission must determine that the amount charged under the contract harms the public interest if, after the evidentiary hearing on public interest, the commission concludes at least one of the following public interest criteria have been violated:

(1) the protested rate impairs the seller's ability to continue to provide service, based on the seller's financial integrity and operational capability;

(2) the protested rate impairs the purchaser's ability to continue to provide service to its retail customers, based on the purchaser's financial integrity and operational capability;

(3) the protested rate evidences the seller's abuse of monopoly power in its provision of water or sewer service to the purchaser. In making this inquiry, the commission must weigh all relevant factors. The factors may include:

(A) the disparate bargaining power of the parties, including the purchaser's alternative means, alternative costs, environmental impact, regulatory issues, and problems of obtaining alternative water or sewer service;

(B) the seller's failure to reasonably demonstrate the changed conditions that are the basis for a change in rates;

(C) the seller changed the computation of the revenue requirement or rate from one methodology to another;

(D) any other valuable consideration received incident to the contract;

(E) incentives necessary to encourage regional projects or water conservation measures;

(F) the seller's obligation to meet federal and state wastewater discharge and drinking water standards;

(G) the rates charged in Texas by other sellers of water or sewer service for resale; or

(H) the seller's rates for water or sewer service charged to its retail customers, compared to the retail rates the purchaser charges its retail customers as a result of the rate the seller demands from the purchaser; or

(4) the protested rate is unreasonably preferential, prejudicial, or discriminatory, compared to the rates the seller charges other customers.

The agency certifies that legal counsel has reviewed the adoption and found it to be a valid exercise of the agency's legal authority.

Filed with the Office of the Secretary of State on November 5, 2026.

TRD-202604665

Katelyn Lewis

Rules Coordinator

Public Utility Commission of Texas

Effective date: November 25, 2026

Proposal publication date: May 22, 2026

For further information, please call: (512) 936-7044